Top Down

This web page accompanies “Using Process Mapping to Identify Patient Safety Hazards in Micro-Systems” in Quality and Safety in Healthcare. by John Grout

Mapping  Approach

Level detail

Hierarch ical

Multiple flows

Org. Struct.

Icons

Logic operators

Flow time

Information/Citations (links to acquire info)

Top- down

 

 

 

 

 

The top-down method is also called a parking lot list. The main process steps are shown across the top and the sub-processes of each are listed below, effectively limiting the level of detail presented.  Parking lot lists are always hierachical in nature.  The hierarchy is express by how the steps are arranged on the map. A step placed below a process step is a lower level in the hierarchy than a step placed beside the previous process step. The top-down aproach is rated as a “weak or implicit” because only one level of hierarchy is specificially provided and no linkages to other maps is invisioned.

an example of a top-down process map that is adapted from the article by DeRosier et al.* is shown below.

see a 2nd example

If top-down maps are turned “on their side,” so that the main process steps are listed vertically, and the subprocess steps are indented, then process mapping can be done using the “outline” capabilities of most common word processing. This would also allow for many layers of hierarchy and increased levels of detail.  Moreover, this alteration to the approach would allow process information to be effectively elicited in group sessions.  The previous example is recast “on its side” below, with added lines indicating opportunities to add sub-sub-processes. This approach is not particularly easy to read, so a graphical presentation should probably created after the information has been elicited.

Altered Top-Down Map Example

 

PSA Test Ordered
             a.  Order Written
                           Sub-sub-process can go here.
                                       sub-sub-sub-process can go here.
                           Sub-sub-process can go here.
 
            b.  Entered in CPRS
                           Sub-sub-process can go here.
                                       sub-sub-sub-process can go here.
             c.  Received in lab
Draw Sample
             a.  ID patien
             b.  Select proper equip
             c.  Draw blood
             d.  Label
Analyze sample
             a.  Review
             b. Centrifuge
             c.  Verify calibration
             d.  RunQC
             e.  Run sample
             f.   Report results
             g.  Enter in CPRS
Report to physician
             a.  Report Received
Results filed (CPRS)
             a.  Telephone
             b.  Visit setup
             c.  Result
 

Top-down mapping offers an implicit or weak display of organizational structure. Organizational structure will normally be revealed only if the main process steps happen to be assignable to specific departments or organizations.

* DeRosier J, Stalhandske E, Bagian J, Nudell T. Using health care failure mode and effect analysis: The VA national center for patient safety’s prospective risk analysis system. Jt Comm J Qual Improv. 2002 May; 28(5):248-267.

[Process Mapping] [Flow Chart] [Top Down] [Swim Lane] [Value Stream]